In leadership class I studied the Lone Ranger approach to problem-solving. When a problem arose in an organization the boss would ride in and solve the problem. Afterwards he or she would ride off and the employees would be no better prepared for the next crisis or problem. The point of the analogy is empowerment – get the individuals to take responsibility for problem-solving.
The same holds true for the relationship between educators and students. All too often educators jump in to solve problems for the students without training students on responsibility. The students are not empowered or held responsible. This problem is magnified for students with special needs.
The most common example occurs during meetings with parents. When a student struggles the first suggestion is often asking teachers if there is additional time available to tutor or help the student individually (parents are not the only ones asking this). The original problem of poor self-help skills is not addressed and the adults shoulder more of the responsibility. As a consequence, the students’ belief that external forces will or are necessary to fix their problems is reinforced.
My suggestion is to look at how the student can be supported as he or she is trained to be more effective in employing self-help skills. Is he taking notes? Is she doing all of her homework? Do the students follow examples in the book or use other resources?
The following are anecdotes of how learned helplessness is developed.
- A student was having problems with a math problem. The para asked if he needed a calculator and walked over to get one for the student.
- A student had notebook organization as the focus of an IEP objective. Each week his PARA was organizing his notebooks for him.
- A special ed teacher started to copy a homework assignment for a student because he didn’t have a pencil.
- Many math teachers, when asked for help, will show students how to do a problem instead of pressing the student to find and follow an example.
The evidence is clear. Students learn to say “I don’t know” and the adults show them what to do as the students passively observe.
2 Replies to “Lone Ranger vs Self-Help”
That sounds like what I’m trying to do with my students! I’m really pushing for them to be more responsible for and accountable for their own learning. Especially the ninth graders. My 6th – 8th graders seem to already get it for the most part. The ninth graders still get frustrated when they aren’t just given an answer or given a formula to use. They’re catching on gradually, but still lots of work to do with them. Luckily I still have half the year left! By the time they leave hopefully they will know how to learn.
Good luck! Not only can that help in hs but for the kids that go on to any type of post-secondary education or training this will be even more important.